The Spice color is just as moisturizing as the other Fresh Sugar Tinted Balms, more like a chapstick than a lip stick. The color is fairly pigmented. Not nearly as much as a lipstick, but way more than your typical colored balm. I'd describe it as a semi-sheer lipstick.
The Fresh Sugar Spice Lip Treatment is a warm rose color which a hint of brown. I think it would be universally flattering since it isn't too pink or too brown. It's really pretty for fall since it pairs well with richer hues like hunter green and burgundy. It isn't too bright for a white tee either, however.
Here it is on my hand-
And on my lips -
It's my favorite new beauty product for fall, I've been wearing Fresh Sugar Spice every day and I'm sure I will continue to all season.
I actually first started reading beauty blogs to check out lipstick swatches. All these years later I feel like they're aren't as many swatches online, at least on the sites I go to, and I miss them! I think they can be really helpful, especially if you don't live near a store that carries the products you like, so I'm going to try and provide some more of them here on All That Glitters. Are there any you would like to see?